Below is an updated tally of the number of times each of the jokers has been punished on every season and a grand total for the entire series.
So who is the most punished joker?
| Guest Star | Episode |
|---|---|
| Rosie O'Donnell | Season 2 Episode 22 - Everything's Just Rosie |
| Imagine Dragons | Season 2 Episode 23 - Enter the Dragons |
| Joey Fatone | Season 3 Episode 6 - Toasted |
| Season 5 Episode 26 - Nitro Circus Spectacular | |
| Season 6 Episode 12 - Crickets | |
| Tommy Dreamer | Season 3 Episode 23 - The Lost Boy |
| Season 6 Episode 4 - Catastrophe | |
| Danica McKellar | Season 4 Episode 6 - The Blunder Years |
| Grant Marshall | Season 4 Episode 7 - Deal With The Devils |
| Colin White | Season 4 Episode 7 - Deal With The Devils |
| Ulambayaryn Byambajav aka Byamba | Season 4 Episode 11 - Pseudo-Sumo |
| Season 7 Episode 12 - Bull Shiatsu | |
| Howie Mandel | Season 4 Episode 21 - Live Punishment Special |
| Gary Busey | Season 6 Episode 2 - Lady and the Tramp |
| Season 7 Episode 1 - The Marathon Man | |
| Season 7 Episode 26 - Staten Island Holiday Spectacular | |
| Bryan Johnson | Season 6 Episode 2 - Lady and the Tramp |
| Noah Syndergaard aka Thor | Season 6 Episode 23 - Take Me Out at The Ball Game |
| Kayla Harrison | Season 6 Episode 24 - The Party Crasher |
| Mark LoMonaco aka Bully Ray / Bubba Ray Dudley | Season 6 Episode 4 - Catastrophe |
| Jamie Lynn Szantyr aka Velvet Sky | Season 6 Episode 4 - Catastrophe |
| Jesse Bravo | Season 6 Episode 8 - Medium, Well Done |
| Matthew Lewis | Season 6 Episode 13 - Universal Appeal |
| Australia's Thunder from Down Under | Season 7 Episode 4 - Stripteased |
| Buddy Valastro | Season 7 Episode 9 - Pulling the Rug |
| Mike Spano | Season 7 Episode 10 - Speech Impediment |
| Guy Fieri | Season 7 Episode 17 - Like a Boss |
| Carlos Peña | Season 7 Episode 21 - Out of Left Field |
| Mark DeRosa | Season 7 Episode 21 - Out of Left Field |
| Tino Martinez | Season 7 Episode 22 - Autograph Corrector |
| Randy Couture | Season 7 Episode 25 - Pantsing With the Stars |
| Blue Man Group | Season 8 Episode 5 - Blue Man Dupe |
| Kevin Smith and Jason Mewes aka Jay and Silent Bob | Season 8 Episode 24 - Hollywood |
| Jeff Daniels | Season 8 Episode 26 - Rock Bottom |
| Jameela Jamil | Season 9 Episode 1 - You Dirty Dog |
As of Season 8, Sal is still the most punished of the jokers closely followed behind by Murr. At the helm with the least amount of punishments is Joe who is distantly followed by Q.
